How Publishers Should Handle Google’s Cookie Reversal

September 2024

#Google Cookie Reversal

With Google reversing its plan to phase out third-party cookies, publishers face a critical decision. In this blog post, we explain why shifting to a first-party data strategy is still the best move for the future.

TV is full of “will-they-won’t-they” romances. You’ve certainly encountered it: two characters with a lot of chemistry keep flirting, maybe getting together and breaking up again, perpetually dancing around the idea of a “happily ever after.”

Sam and Diane on Cheers, Ryan and Marissa on The O.C., Maddie and David on Moonlighting—these shows often draw out the tension for years, keeping audiences hooked with the promise of a resolution that never quite arrives. It’s a strategy that keeps viewers invested, but eventually, many start feeling frustrated with the endless will-they-won’t-they dance, wishing the writers would just make up their minds.

This has been the experience for publishers watching Google’s tumultuous relationship with third-party tracking cookies. The situation was on, then off, then definitely on, then delayed, and delayed, and delayed again. The drama of it all has been exhausting, but now the will-they-won’t-they is finally resolved, and the answer is? They won’t.

Having a definitive answer is beneficial, regardless of where you stand on this issue, as it allows your business to finally chart a course for the future. In this blog, we’ll explore what Google’s latest decision means for online publishing and why we still believe that investing in a first-party data strategy might be the wiser path forward. Read on:

Table of Contents

Blog: Publishing in the Age of Google Adtech Dominance: Read More

First-Party Data: The Gold Standard

We’ve explained the difference between the different types of data collection before, but in short, first-party data is information collected by you, from your audience, providing a more-accurate understanding of your users. Third-party cookies rely on aggregated data from various external sources, while first-party data is specific to your own website or app — meaning you can gather precise insights into user behavior, preferences, and engagement directly from the proverbial horse’s mouth.

By leveraging first-party data, you gain control over the quality and granularity of the information you collect. And because of that, you can tailor your user experience directly for your specific users. For example, you can use first-party data to refine your content strategy, optimize ad targeting, and improve user journeys based on real interactions rather than guesstimates.

Plus, first-party data is less susceptible to inaccuracies compared to third-party data, which can be fragmented or outdated. After all, you know how the data was collected and stored, and you have complete control over the process. By focusing on data that you collect and manage yourself, you ensure that your insights are up-to-date and reflective of your current audience dynamics, ultimately enhancing the effectiveness of your marketing and engagement strategies.

Blog: First, Second, & Third-Party Data: What It Is, How To Collect It Read More

Navigating Global Privacy Regulations

While it can occasionally seem like Google runs the whole world, it’s important to remember they aren’t the only force deciding whether we get to keep using third-party tracking cookies. Jurisdictions around the world have begun implementing strict privacy regulations, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Europe and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) in the United States. These regulations impose strict requirements on data collection, user consent, and data protection, and they vary significantly across different regions — and, more-importantly, many of them are stricter than what Google itself mandates or allows.

Third-party cookies, which track users across multiple sites, often face scrutiny under these regulations due to their invasive nature and the difficulty in managing user consent effectively. By contrast, first-party data collection involves direct interaction with users, making it easier to comply with privacy laws. When you collect data directly from your audience, you can obtain explicit consent and provide transparent information about how their data will be used, aligning with regulatory requirements more seamlessly.

While you can, currently, continue to use third-party cookies, you may find yourself having to tailor your strategy for various legal spheres. Streamlining and perfecting your first-party strategy instead will allow you to use the same approach no matter whose laws you’re operating under.

Blog: Privacy For Publishers: What You Need To Know Read More

The Risk of Future Reversals

While the decision to abandon cookie deprecation can feel comparatively decisive, so too was Google’s decision to deprecate cookies in the first place. Though you might decide on December 31st to quit smoking, join a gym, and cut out fatty foods, there’s not actually anything stopping you from making the exact-opposite decision when the alarm goes off on January 1st. Basically, any decision you can make you can un-make, and Google is no different in this regard. How many hard deadlines on cookie deprecation have we left in the dust over the past few years?

This might indicate that cookies are just too inextricable from the adtech ecosystem, but it could also just mean that that’s the case for now. The landscape of digital advertising remains in flux, and while this announcement is causing some folks to breathe a sigh of relief, you may still not want to build your house on sand.

In essence, relying on first-party data provides a level of stability and control that’s less vulnerable to external fluctuations. It empowers you to maintain consistent and reliable insights into your audience, regardless of the evolving landscape of digital tracking and privacy.

Forbes: Cookie Deprecation is Delayed Again — Now What? Read More

Enhanced Experience Through Personalization

One of the coolest things technological developments have done over the past decade is provide a bespoke, custom experience for people where there used to only be a one-size-fits-all approach. First-party data gives you the opportunity to enhance your user experience through more-precise personalization, whether that’s in providing better-tailored content, more-targeted content recommendations, and more.

First-party data is also great for implementing a dynamic creative optimization (DCO) strategy. In DCO, advertisers can target user profiles based on their specific online behaviors, meaning that the ads run on publisher pages can be more-targeted, more-effective, and more-profitable. This improvement in ROI can turn into increased revenue for publishers.

Plus, personalized experiences just feel better for users. Getting a present from someone is good, but getting a present that feels like they truly listened to you is always better. Providing an experience that feels more tailored to your user base will result in better community, more time-on-site, and more return visits.

Blog: the COOL company strengthens market position with acquisition of ADventori: Read More

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, while Google’s decision to delay the deprecation of third-party cookies might seem like a temporary win for publishers, the advantages of adopting a first-party data strategy remain compelling and far-reaching. First-party data offers greater reliability, easier compliance with global privacy regulations, and protection against potential future disruptions.

By investing in a first-party data approach, you not only enhance your understanding of your audience but also future-proof your data strategy.

If you’re a publisher looking to future-proof your data strategy, COOL companies like Insticator and OKO offer solutions. Reach out to our team to learn how we can help you leverage first-party data effectively and stay ahead of whatever they throw at us next.

Written by
Sean Kelly, Senior Content Writer

Sean Kelly is a Senior Content Specialist, St. Louis-based engagement expert with 20 years of experience in content writing, and 8 years in adtech.

komalchand gaidhane

Written by

komalchand gaidhane